If cost is not a factor, you're not into bar deep mud, and you've had good luck with your stockers then IMO go with a Bighorn. Possibly the new Terra if proves to be more durable. I wish ITP would construct the ATR's with the new Terra design. By far, my favorite tire, other than it wore quickly and if you looked at it wrong you'd get a flat tire. Till the improve themselves, I'll stick with the Bighorns.